Malta vs Sicily: Which Island Fits Your Travel Style

Compare Malta and Sicily on transport, food, beaches, and daily costs, plus the ferry between them, so you can pick the right Mediterranean island.

Ekin Yalgın

May 31, 2026·6 min read

Malta vs Sicily: Which Island Fits Your Travel Style

A common mistake travelers make when choosing between Malta and Sicily is assuming they need the same time and the same logistics. Sicily needs at least ten days and a rental car to barely scratch the surface, while Malta lets you cover an entire country on local buses in a long weekend. The two islands sit just 81 kilometers apart, yet they ask for completely different trips. This guide breaks down getting there, cost, beaches, food, days needed, and the ferry that links them.

Feature	Malta	Sicily
Size	316 km² (compact)	25,711 km² (vast)
Ideal trip length	4 to 7 days	10 to 14+ days
Primary transport	Public bus, Bolt, ferries	Rental car, regional trains
Daily budget	€80 to €120	€70 to €130 plus car rental
Key highlights	Megalithic temples, diving, walkable cities	Mount Etna, Greek ruins, food culture

Both islands are cheaper than mainland Italy or Northern Europe, but the way you spend differs. Malta saves you money on transport, while Sicily rewards you with low food prices and forces a car cost on you.

Size and Getting Around

Malta is incredibly compact, measuring just 27 kilometers long. You can travel between major historical sites, beach towns, and the Gozo ferry terminal without ever renting a car. The public bus network covers the whole island, though routes slow down in heavy summer traffic.

Ride-hailing apps like Bolt run efficiently and stay affordable on short hops, and Valletta itself is fully pedestrianized and small enough to explore on foot. Sicily is the largest island in the Mediterranean and over 80 times larger than Malta. Relying on public transport alone confines you to hubs like Palermo or Catania. To reach the Baroque towns of Val di Noto or hidden coastal reserves, a rental car is essential.

Be ready for assertive local driving, narrow mountain roads, and busy city traffic. Driving from Palermo in the west to Syracuse in the east takes at least three hours.

Rental car on a narrow winding mountain road through rocky Sicilian hills — Exploring inland Sicily means narrow mountain roads and assertive local traffic, so a rental car and steady nerves are essential.

If you want the full picture on hiring a car for the smaller island, renting a car and driving in Malta comes with its own costs and quirks.

Beaches and Coastal Vibe

Malta is not a traditional sandy beach destination. The coastline is dominated by dramatic limestone cliffs, deep blue water, and rocky inlets like St. Peter's Pool.

These spots offer world-class visibility for scuba diving and snorkeling. If you want soft sand, head specifically to northern bays like Golden Bay, or take a boat to the famous Blue Lagoon on Comino. Sicily offers a much wider range of classic beach days. You will find long white-sand stretches at San Vito Lo Capo and lively seaside resorts like Cefalu.

The island also has volcanic beaches with inky black sand, especially on a side trip to the Aeolian Islands. The sheer length of the Sicilian coastline means you can find an empty cove even in high season.

Secluded turquoise cove framed by cliffs on the Sicilian coast — Sicily's sheer length of coastline means you can still find an empty cove with clear water even at the height of summer.

For a closer look at where to swim on the smaller island, the best beaches in Malta and Gozo range from sandy bays to rocky coves.

Food Culture: Pastizzi vs Arancini

Maltese cuisine is a rustic blend of Mediterranean staples and North African influences.

Local menus feature hearty rabbit stews, octopus cooked in garlic, and ftira, a thick-crusted flatbread. Street food is highly affordable, with a savory cheese or pea pastizzi costing less than a euro. Coffee leans pricier, often above €2 for a standard espresso. Sicily carries serious culinary weight and ranks among Europe's top food destinations. You meet dishes locals eat daily, not tourist novelties, from the eggplant and ricotta of pasta alla Norma to pistachio-filled cannoli.

The street markets in Palermo, like Ballaro, serve deep-fried arancini and chickpea fritters for a few coins, alongside the classic €1 Italian espresso. If Maltese flavors win you over, traditional Maltese food shows you exactly what to order.

Historical Sites and Attractions

The density of history in Malta is staggering for its size. The island holds UNESCO-listed Megalithic Temples dating to 3600 BC, making them older than the Egyptian pyramids.

Valletta stands as a pristine Baroque fortress city built by the Knights of St. John, while the walled medieval city of Mdina feels frozen in time, with narrow stone labyrinths and no car traffic. Sicily delivers a sweeping timeline of ancient empires and volcanic landscapes. The Valley of the Temples in Agrigento features some of the most intact Greek architecture outside Greece. Towering over the eastern coast, Mount Etna offers lunar landscapes and active volcanic hiking trails. The contrast is sharp, from the Arab-Norman palaces of Palermo to the cliffside Greek theatre in Taormina.

Lone hiker on a black gravel trail across a volcanic landscape in Sicily — Beyond beaches, Sicily delivers lunar volcanic landscapes and active hiking trails that Malta simply cannot match in scale.

Cost Breakdown: Which Island Is Cheaper?

Daily expenses on both islands are fairly comparable. Malta offers slightly cheaper accommodation outside the sought-after Valletta center, and you save a meaningful amount simply by skipping car rental and fuel. Restaurant dining, though, runs higher in Malta, where eating out can cost noticeably more than in Sicily.

Sicily provides exceptional value for food, especially at local trattorias and street stalls, and guesthouses in the interior and smaller coastal towns are budget-friendly. The catch is the mandatory car hire, insurance, and highway tolls, which push a typical Sicilian day above a bus-based Malta day. For a realistic line-by-line breakdown, Malta travel costs tally daily spend by travel style.

Can You Do Both?

The Malta to Sicily Ferry

If you have enough time, you do not strictly have to choose. Virtu Ferries runs a high-speed catamaran from Valletta to Pozzallo in southern Sicily in about 1 hour 45 minutes, with the Valletta to Catania crossing taking roughly 4 hours 15 minutes. Foot-passenger fares start around EUR 72, with a round-trip day-trip ticket commonly near EUR 130.

Many travelers use Malta as a base and book organized day trips to Sicily. These usually leave early, take you up the slopes of Mount Etna, and allow an afternoon in Taormina before returning by nightfall.

It is a long, tiring day, but it removes the headache of driving Sicily yourself. A Malta to Sicily day trip walks through the ferry logistics and Etna tours.

Passengers on the deck of a catamaran ferry crossing between Malta and Sicily — The fast ferry lets you sample Sicily on a long day trip, removing the headache of driving the larger island yourself.

The Final Verdict: Malta or Sicily?

Your available days dictate the right choice.

Pick Malta if you have five to seven days and want a high concentration of history, deep-water swimming, and simple logistics. The small scale lets you see the main island, Gozo, and Comino without exhaustion. Book flights to Sicily if you have ten to fourteen days and crave a slow road trip. The island rewards travelers who want to drive through dramatic mountain passes, explore varied ruins, and dig into a world-renowned food culture.

And if you cannot decide, the fast ferry means you do not always have to.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Daily budgets are close on both islands, but the cost shifts in different places. In Malta you save on transport because you can use buses and ride-hailing instead of a rental car, though restaurant dining tends to run higher. In Sicily food and guesthouses are excellent value, but the mandatory car hire, insurance, and highway tolls usually push your daily spend above a bus-based trip in Malta. Plan on roughly 80 to 120 euros a day in Malta and a similar range in Sicily once you add the car.

Yes, and many travelers do. The two islands sit only about 81 kilometers apart, and a high-speed Virtu Ferries catamaran links them. You can use Malta as your base and either take an organized day trip to Mount Etna and Taormina or cross over for a few nights to explore Sicily at your own pace. If you want to do both islands justice, give yourself at least ten to twelve days total.

The fast Virtu Ferries catamaran from Valletta to Pozzallo in southern Sicily takes about 1 hour 45 minutes, while the longer crossing to Catania runs roughly 4 hours 15 minutes. Foot-passenger fares start around 72 euros one way, and a round-trip day-trip ticket is commonly near 130 euros. Prices vary by season, sailing time, and whether you bring a vehicle, so book ahead in summer.

Malta is the easier pick for a first trip, especially if your time is limited. It is compact, English is widely spoken, the bus network reaches most sights, and you can see the main highlights in under a week without renting a car. Sicily is more rewarding for travelers who are comfortable driving and have ten days or more, since it is huge and the best parts are spread out.

It depends on what you mean by a good beach. Malta is built around dramatic limestone cliffs, deep clear water, and rocky coves that are ideal for snorkeling and diving, with only a handful of sandy bays like Golden Bay and the Blue Lagoon on Comino. Sicily has far more classic sandy stretches, from San Vito Lo Capo to volcanic black-sand beaches, and its long coastline means you can usually find a quiet cove even in high season.

Four to seven days is enough to enjoy Malta well. In that time you can explore Valletta and the Three Cities, visit Mdina and the Megalithic Temples, take the ferry to Gozo, and spend a day swimming at the Blue Lagoon on Comino. Because the island is so small, you cover a lot without long transfers, which is why it works so well for a long weekend or a one-week trip.

Plan for at least ten days, and ideally two weeks, to see Sicily properly. The island is more than 80 times larger than Malta, and driving from one side to the other can take three hours or more. With ten to fourteen days you can combine Palermo, the Greek ruins at Agrigento, Mount Etna, and the Baroque towns of the southeast without rushing.

You do not need a car in Malta. The bus network covers the whole island, ride-hailing apps like Bolt are cheap for short trips, and Valletta is pedestrianized. In Sicily a rental car is essentially required if you want to go beyond the main cities, since public transport leaves you stuck around Palermo or Catania and many of the best towns and beaches are hard to reach otherwise.

Sicily is the stronger food destination overall and ranks among the best in Europe, with bold regional dishes like pasta alla Norma, fresh seafood, arancini, and cannoli, plus famously cheap espresso. Maltese food is more rustic and North African in flavor, built around rabbit stew, octopus, ftira flatbread, and pastizzi pastries that cost less than a euro. If food is your main reason to travel, Sicily edges ahead.

Malta is generally easier with kids because distances are short, you avoid the stress of driving on busy Sicilian roads, and attractions are close together. Sicily can be wonderful for families too, with sandy beaches and Mount Etna, but it suits households comfortable with longer drives and a slower, more spread-out itinerary.

Published in

Malta